Page 1 of 4 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 34

Thread: What to look for in a tent

  1. #1
    Claptrap's Problem Solver



    The Stig's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    Shelton
    Posts
    3,115

    What to look for in a tent

    Original webpage at consumersearch.com

    Most tents now come with bathtub floors, which keep seams several inches above the ground, and "no-see-um" mesh to keep out the tiniest insects. Double-track door zippers let you unzip the fabric door while leaving a screen in place for insect protection. Color-coding makes setup easier, though experts still recommend practicing with a new tent at home before taking it on a trip. Reviewers say to look for the following additional features when buying a tent:

    Consider your priorities. For family camping, allow plenty of space for playing inside on rainy days, and look for good storage to keep everyone's belongings neat. For backpacking, balance light weight with size; a tent that's light but cramped may not provide a good night's sleep.

    Bigger isn't always better. A tent that's too big or too oddly shaped may not fit onto the tent pads at many campgrounds. Also, the bigger the tent, the harder it may be to stay warm during cool weather.

    Full-coverage rain flies are best. Quite a few tents increase ventilation by providing only partial-coverage rain flies that include little awnings over the windows and doors. Reviewers say these are adequate in a light rain, but can let in driving rain. It's better to have a rainproof tent that increases ventilation with cleverly placed vents.

    Factory-taped seams are important for rain protection. However, tent experts recommend using seam sealer on a tent periodically anyway. Some inexpensive tents need seam sealing before the first use.

    Look for plenty of storage pockets and loops. Both owners and professional reviewers say that built-in storage makes a big difference in tent livability. Some tents come with plenty of interior storage, while others make gear lofts available only at extra cost.

    Ventilation is crucial to minimize condensation. Look for mesh placed both low on a tent wall and high in the roof for good airflow. Ideally, you can open and close vent covers from inside the tent even with the rain fly on. Tents with a rain fly, known as double-wall tents, usually provide the best combination of ventilation and storm protection. Single-wall waterproof fabric is usually used only on tents designed for ultralight backpacking, where a little condensation isn't as important as light weight. Some hybrid backpacking tents are partly double-wall, partly single-wall, to balance these factors.

    Double doors are a big convenience. They add ventilation and minimize having to climb over someone else to enter or exit the tent. They also make it easier to decide how to pitch the tent to get good views, privacy and resistance to wind and rain.

    Two vestibules are better than one. You can store gear on one side and cook on the other if it's raining outside. Large vestibules also let a dog sleep in protected space, yet outside the tent. Experts recommend a vestibule of at least 6 square feet, so you can store a pack in it as well as boots.

    Shock-corded poles, color-coding and quick clips make for fast setup. Shock-corded poles fold into sections for compact storage, but unfold quickly to full length. Clipping the tent to the poles is faster than having to thread the poles through sleeves. Color coding means that the pole tips are matched to specific tabs around the grommets where they're supposed to go. Some tents have the setup instructions printed right on the carry sack, especially useful for large family tents with lots of pole parts.

    Even lifetime tent warranties don't cover sun degradation of the fabric. To prevent sun degradation, canvas is the best tent material, polyester next. Plain nylon has the least resistance to ultraviolet rays. If a tent is used only a week or two a year, pitched mostly in the shade, this is less important.

    Aluminum poles are stronger -- but heavier -- than carbon-fiber poles. Some family tents use steel poles, which are heavy and eventually rust. Reviews don't recommend tents that use fiberglass poles, because they're prone to splintering. Variable-diameter poles are designed to minimize tent weight, putting the largest diameter where the most strength is needed.

    Single-wall backpacking tents are lightest. These eliminate the rain fly, making the tent body either from breathable rainproof fabric or from silicon. Most breathable fabric tents can't be treated with fire retardant, so they can't be shipped to some states or to Canada. Silicon fabrics have an electrostatic attraction to pollen, sand and dust.

    Square footage doesn't tell the whole story. This measurement is a starting point to help you decide if a tent is big enough, but also check length to be sure your sleeping bag or cot will fit. Total interior space (measured in cubic feet) depends on the tent's shape. A-frame tents less interior space than hoop, dome and umbrella tents. Within types there's still variation in available space, so look for a design that maximizes it.

    Headroom is important. For a family tent, make sure the headroom allows the tallest person in the group to stand up inside. For a backpacking tent, make sure there's space for everyone to sit up. It's possible to get dressed without sitting up, but it's not comfortable. Being able to sit up comfortably also makes rainy days inside the tent much more tolerable.

    Stakes and guy lines that are brightly colored are easier to see. Some tent stakes even have a reflective coating so you can move around the tent site with a flashlight without tripping over guy lines. Colored stakes also make it easier to avoid leaving some behind when you pack up to leave. We found many owner-written reviews recommending replacing cheap metal stakes (which are prone to bending) with heavy-duty plastic stakes.

    A footprint or groundcloth protects the tent floor. Most tents have an optional footprint you can buy, that's already shaped to fit under the tent with a margin of a few inches all around. (Counter-intuitively, the tent footprint must be a little smaller than the tent, not larger.) To save money, you can make your own out of Tyvek or 4-mil black plastic.

    I've only slept in a tent a few times so I'd be interested to hear what our tenting regulars have to say about this list.
    If you think that come SHTF you are gonna jock up in all your kit and be a death-dealing one man army, you're an idiot - izzyscout

  2. #2
    Damn the propane, save the bacon!


    LUNCHBOX's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    OHIO
    Posts
    1,418
    The list is awesome, I wished I was out somewhere in one to read all that...LOL. I would say that the ground tarp is a good idea for a barrier but I wouldn't choose the bright guidelines or reflective stakes due to visual security. It's a good article to use as a "what to look for list"
    Be ready now, you won't have that chance later.

  3. #3
    Crotch Rocket


    mitunnelrat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    Eastern MI
    Posts
    3,191
    I'm with LUNCHBOX on this one.
    Consilio et animis

    Essayons!

  4. #4
    The hot sexy one

    TroubleShooter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    181
    I think tent choice is like picking your choice of weapon.............You need to know what you want the tent to do, My tent for family camping is not the same as my tent for backpacking or bugging out........A tarp ,a quality high end sleeping bag, and bug netting......... goes a long way in a SHTF... I try to make everything I carry a dual purpose item....

  5. #5
    Thunder Lizard Canning Club Chapter of the Old Farts Society


    Grumpy Old Man's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    Galts Gulch, God's Country
    Posts
    2,293
    That's a good starting point. I had a long comment on this, but I type so slow that I had to refresh to post it and lost it in the process.
    Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me Liberty or give me death." Patrick Henry, Virginia House of Burgesses, March 23, 1775

    Quo Vadis?

    Luke 22:36, And he that hath no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one.

    emergencyfoodssupplies.com

  6. #6
    Damn the propane, save the bacon!


    LUNCHBOX's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    OHIO
    Posts
    1,418
    I do agree with Troubleshooter on this...my tent has a full inside net and a full top cover but it is very light and just a two man. (Around 3 lbs)---made by a company named Swiss if I remember right. (At work now)
    Be ready now, you won't have that chance later.

  7. #7
    Resident Seafood Procurement Officer


    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    946
    I still want to find the tent that has small enough mesh to keep out the Florida "no see ums". Little bastards are nothing but flying teeth.

  8. #8
    I'll most likely shit myself



    bacpacker's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    East Tennessee
    Posts
    7,602
    Great article that covered a lot of stuff. If you will be using it in a humid area I would go for a tent with a rain fly and plenty of mesh. If the tent don't vent well everything inside will be wet eventually, espically if you cook in it. I highly suggest not cookin in the tent anyway, way to easy to attract critters. I'll have to post about my bear story sometime.

    I agree with several of the troubleshooter and Lunchbox. Know what you need for the scenarios and purpose you want to fill. Much better choices that way.

  9. #9
    Crotch Rocket


    mitunnelrat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    Eastern MI
    Posts
    3,191
    I agree with that as well. The tent I take car camping, which isn't all that, is much different from then tent in my BOB. The article listed a number of features that I want when I get around to making an informed purchase for a new leisure tent for family camping, but I'm pretty happy with my Solitaire. Specifically due to its low profile as an individual shelter in my BOB.
    Consilio et animis

    Essayons!

  10. #10
    NVG....totally a work deduction!


    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    179
    I have many tents, they all serve different purposes.

    I have a one person winter/mountain tent, it has great coverage, but would suck in the summer in texas, reasonably light for a winter tent.
    I have a two person hiking tent which is good, but not quite enough for winter, lightweight.
    I have a 4 person tent I use when camping near my vehicle, very roomy but heavy.

    They all have different uses, but lately unless I am sharing with others, I don't use a tent when hiking, just a bivy sack with a tarp. The tarp allows me to sit up and have a sheltered place, while the bivy sack keeps the bugs out and the bedding dry and warm. The tarp keeps my stuff covered and allows me to keep the bivy sack open, with just the netting zipped shut, (i really hate fully closing the sack, the opening can be closed with netting, or fully closed)

    There are just too many different climates and uses for a tent to have a single list. It needs to be large enough, strong enough, light enough, but how much of each varies a lot by usage. When camping out a festival, I want something large and roomy, but light is not a primary concern. Hiking the weight and strength are primary.

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •